The 8 Best Cookie Scoops
When we make cookies, we want them all to be nice and even. Presentation is everything! A good set of cookie scoops are essential tools to make that happen and have more fun during the process.
But don’t just get any scoops! We’ve tested the best ones out there and collected them here. So let’s dive in 🙂
Our Top List
# | Preview | Product | Our Rating | Link |
1 |  | Saebye Cookie Scoop Set | ||
2 |  | Apexstone 3x Cookie Scoop Set | ||
3 |  | Jenaluca Cookie & Cupcake Scoop | ||
4 |  | Sangde Cookie Scoop for Baking & Ice Cream | ||
5 |  | Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Scoops | ||
6 |  | Pit Boss 6qt Cast Iron Roaster and Griddle Lid | ||
7 |  | OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop | ||
8 |  | Earl Diamond - Stainless Steel Cookie & Ice Cream Scoop |
1. Saebye Cookie Scoop Set
Having this cookie scoop set on hand when you bake is convenient, and different-sized scoops let you meet a huge range of needs. You’ll get three scoops that are small, medium, and large when you order this kit, and the small scoop will hold up to 1.5-tablespoons while the medium one will hold up to 2.8-tablespoons, and the large size can hold up to 5.4-tablespoons at one time. This allows you to make a large range of cookies that will all come out a consistent size, and this is great for presentations or if you’re going to make them for parties.
These cookie scoops feature 18/8 stainless steel with a very nice finish that makes them easy to spot in the drawer or on the counter, and they also use food-grade materials that won’t flake off into your food. There isn’t a spring mechanism to release the cookie dough, though, and these cookie scoops use a cog-and-ratchet mechanism that cleanly removes the dough from the scoop while saving you hand and wrist fatigue. The arc-style handle gives you an excellent ergonomic grip, and this product won’t scratch or chip with heavy usage. This set is our top choice for the best cookie scoop and also great for making ice cream orbs.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: Stainless, food-grade steel
- Size: Three sizes
Pros
- Comes with a small, medium, and large scoop
- Uses food-grade materials
- Cog-and-ratchet release
- Mirror polish
- Easy to clean
Cons
- None that we could find
2. Apexstone 3x Cookie Scoop Set
You’ll get a triple pack of cookie scoops when you purchase this set from Apexstone, and they can hold 0.75-ounces, 1.33-ounces, and 2.67-ounces without a problem. You can get three decent-quality cookie scoops while saving a little money as they come as a package deal, and they use 304 stainless steel in the design that is tough and strong enough to protect against breakage and bending while resisting rust and corrosion. This is a great product if you plan on using them for years, and they come with a pretty polish on them that makes them easy to see.
You can clean these cookie scoops by hand or in the dishwasher without a problem, and they’ll regain their bright sheen once you put them through the dishwasher. The handle comes coated with a plastic material that is comfortable to grasp while providing you a non-slip grip that is comfortable. There is a trigger mechanism that allows you to quickly and easily release a neat ball of dough to give you uniform results, and the trigger has a broader base for your thumb to rest when you press it.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: 304 stainless steel with plastic handles
- Size: Three sizes
Pros
- Handles are soft and comfortable
- Three sizes in each package
- Has a nice sheen
- Resists corrosion and rust
- Prevents hand fatigue
Cons
-
Plastic coating can wear out
3. Jenaluca Cookie & Cupcake Scoop
Cookie scoops should be beautiful and well-made to ensure they last for years of heavy use, and it doesn’t hurt if it comes in attractive packaging when you first get it. You’ll get a very nice rectangular, white package that has the company name written on it when you purchase it, and this gives you a nice place to store it between uses to make sure it looks nice and stays where you can reach it. The inside of the case has blue velvet fabric, and the cookie scoop itself comes made out of 18/8 stainless steel that gives it the strength it needs to prevent it from bending when you use it.
You can choose from five sizes when you order, ranging from small to jumbo, and this allows you to tailor your purchase to your intended usage to get uniform and nice-looking cookies. The cog glides quickly and easily when you push the handle without applying a huge amount of pressure, and this can save your hands from fatigue. It won’t corrode, rust, or tarnish with repeated use, and you can stick it into the dishwasher to clean it between uses because it has a mirror finish on it.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: 18/8 stainless steel
- Size: One
Pros
- Mirror polish on it
- Cog glides smoothly
- 18/8 stainless steel
- Easy to clean
- Five sizes available
Cons
-
May have problems with chilled dough
4. Sangde Cookie Scoop for Baking & Ice Cream
When you make cookies, you may want to make more than one size at a time, so buying a set of scoops that come with different sizes helps to fill this need without having a large price tag on it. You’ll get a small number 12 scoop, a medium number 24 scoop, and a large number 50 scoop in each order, and the small cookie scoop can hold 0.8-ounces, the medium can hold 1.4-ounces, and the large cookie scoop can hold 2.7-ounces to create uniform looks when the cookies bake. These cookie scoops also have a very timeless look to them because they’re made out of durable 18/8 stainless steel.
The stainless steel is durable enough to resist corrosion and rust, and there is a mirror finish on them that makes them shiny enough to use indoors or outdoors without losing them. The material used to make this cookie dough scoop is food-grade, so it’s safe to use, and you’ll notice that it works with a cog-and-ratchet mechanism that allows it to smoothly glide when you use it to prevent fatigue in your hands and wrists. They’re easy to clean, easy to maintain, and you can easily use them for years at a time.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: 18/8 stainless steel
- Size: Three sizes
Pros
- Cog-and-ratchet mechanism
- Three sizes available
- Holds from 0.8-ounces to 2.7-ounces
- Has a mirror finish
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Edges are a bit sharp
5. Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Scoops
This cookie scoop set has many applications. You can easily use them to prepare cookies or cupcakes, make melon balls, or fill ice cream without a problem. These applications can require a few sizes, so buying a set of cookie scoops that have three different sizes is a great idea because you get more versatility without raising the price tag. You get three scoops that can hold one tablespoon to make it ideal for melon balls or small cookies, scoops that can hold 1.5-tablespoons for regular cookies, and scoops that can hold up to three tablespoons that is suitable for cupcakes or muffin batter.
This cookie scoop is built to last because it features stainless steel with no plastic parts, and metal is resistant to rust, bending, breaking, wear, or tear under heavy usage. There is a spring release mechanism that is very easy to operate because you don’t need a lot of pressure to work the release mechanism, and you won’t fatigue your hands. The handles won’t slip in your grip, and you get a very shiny finish on them that makes these cookie scoops easy to spot when you put them down.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: Stainless steel
- Size: Three
Pros
- Spring release mechanism
- Comes in three sizes
- Ergonomic handles
- No plastic parts
- Nice for heavy usage
Cons
-
Release mechanism is thin
6. Solula Professional Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop
A nice gift is one that has an elegant design with high-quality materials that can help it last for years with repeated use, and this is exactly what you get when you pick out this cookie scoop. This cookie scoop comes designed to make consistently round balls of dough to give you uniform cookies as they bake and spread out, and this is great if you plan on serving them at an event where presentation counts. Scoops can easily vary hugely in size while not every size works well for your needs, so this cookie scoop brand offers a large range of sizes from 2.2-ounces up to 0.48 ounces.
This particular cookie scoop is a size 50 with a diameter of 1.5-inches, and it holds up to 0.6-ounces of dough. Durability is one of the best selling points with this cookie scoop, and it features 18/8 stainless steel for the material that won’t tarnish, corrode, rust, break, or bend with heavy use. It has a spring mechanism that allows you to easily release the cookie dough from the scoop in consistent balls.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: 18/8 stainless steel
- Size: 14 sizes
Pros
- Highly durable
- Comes in 14 sizes
- Easy to use
- Won’t corrode, rust, or tarnish
- Spring mechanism
Cons
-
Sweeper only goes halfway across the scoop
7. OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop
OXO Good Grips is a company that is very well-known for creating high-quality products that can last for years without showing wear and tear, and it comes with a unique construction that you won’t find in other options. The rubber material on the handles of this cookie scoop provides you a lot more comfort when you use it for extended baking sessions, and it can help prevent blisters from forming on your fingers. The release mechanism is also loaded, and you won’t have to apply a huge amount of pressure to release a perfect dough ball.
The rest of this cookie scoop features a durable stainless steel material that makes it very strong while ensuring that it won’t break or bend with repeated use, and it won’t rust, corrode, or tarnish when you wash it by hand or in the dishwasher between uses. The medium-sized scoops can hold right around 1.5-tablespoons of dough in one go, and this creates cookies that are right around 2.75-inches in diameter. There is a large and small model available too that can hold between one and three tablespoons to help you make different-sized cookies.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: Stainless steel with rubberized handles
- Size: Yes
Pros
- Soft rubber handles
- Three sizes available
- Easy to operate
- Reputable company
- Easy to clean
Cons
-
Doesn’t work great on chilled dough
8. Earl Diamond – Stainless Steel Cookie and Ice Cream Scoop
One of the biggest things you have to consider when you shop for a cookie scoop is the construction because a lot of scoops will bend when you put them in chilled dough to make it hard to get the dough onto the baking sheet. This is a professional-grade cookie scoop that comes made out of 304 stainless steel that won’t break, bend, rust, or corrode easily with heavy use, and it can keep looking good for years at a time without showing any regular signs of wear and tear. You’ll get a vintage Mahogany wooden handle on this cookie scoop that has a very fine texture on it while being comfortable to hold.
There is no built-in release system on this handle because it’s solid with a very ergonomic design, but there is a release system attached right below the scoop’s head. It’s 8.2-inches long with a head diameter of 1.9-inches, and you can use it for a broad range of applications in the kitchen, like scooping cookie dough, ice cream, and more. It also works well to make uniform meatballs, melon balls, muffins, or cupcakes, and it’s safe to pop into the dishwasher and clean it between uses.
Key Features:
- Dishwasher-Safe: Yes
- Material: 304 stainless steel with a Mahogany handle
- Size: One
Pros
- Solid wood handle
- Easy to push the trigger mechanism
- Stainless steel head
- Ergonomic design
- Reputable brand
Cons
-
No automatic trigger release mechanism
What is the best cookie scoop?
Saebye Cookie Scoop Set
Pros
- Handles are soft and comfortable
- Three sizes in each package
- Has a nice sheen
- Resists corrosion and rust
- Prevents hand fatigue
Cons
- We have found no issues
Our pick for the best cookie scoop is the Saebye Cookie Scoop Set because it comes in a range of sizes from small to large, and it’s made out of 18/8 stainless steel that is very durable and resistant to common wear and tear that could shorten how long it lasts. We also liked that it came backed by a reputable brand and that it allowed you to make a range of cookies.
These cookie scoops use food-grade materials and come with a sheen that makes them easy to spot in your utensil drawer. Finally, the spring mechanism is nice because it allows you to release neat balls of dough without causing hand or wrist fatigue, and you get a very ergonomic grip.
Buying Guide
When you shop for the best cookie scoop, you want to compare the various products using the same buying criteria to help you narrow down your final choices correctly. This way, you can ensure you get a great product that you’ll be able to use each time you bake or cook, and we’ve picked out the most important features to keep in mind below. You don’t need to be a pro to make great cookies but with a good scoop set and cookie press, you are set to dazzle your family and friends with your cookies! For spices, check out our top list for the best spice racks!
Cookie Scoop Size
The size of your cookie scoop should be one of the biggest factors you keep in mind as you shop, and the size typically refers to the diameter of the scoop because this determines the portion size you end up with. You can get small scoops that hold up to 0.45-ounces of dough, a medium scoop that holds up to 1.1-ounces of dough, or a large scoop that can hold up to 2-ounces of dough. These make cookies that are 1-inch, 1.8-inches, and 2.4-inches in diameter when they bake. Generally speaking, it’s a good idea to get a few different sizes, so you have them on hand should you ever need them.
Construction
You have to consider your cookie scoop’s durability and resilience before you purchase this product as it is going to be around food, and a cheaply-made cookie scoop can easily bend or break when you put it in the chilled dough. You want to use a material like high-grade stainless steel that is food-grade to ensure it won’t bend, break, corrode, rust, or flake off in your dough as you use it. Avoid scoops that are made out of plastic or that have plastic parts, and pay attention to the handle materials because they should also be durable.
Ease of Cleaning
One of the biggest maintenance steps you’ll take with this cookie scoop is to clean it between uses to get all of the dough out of it, and you can help keep the rust away by cleaning it thoroughly and drying it when you finish with it. Stainless steel is usually easy to clean, and you’ll want to find a scoop that is safe to use in the dishwasher because this appliance can clean it very effectively. You want to ensure that you can get in each small crack or crevice of the tool without missing any spots, and this includes in the handle and under the release mechanism in the scoop head.
Brand
It’s always better to go with a reputable brand than one that most people don’t know because reputable brands are more likely to use high-quality materials and have responsive customer service teams. They’ve also had years to perfect their processes and materials to create solid products that are meant to last for years, and they offer more solid warranties. A few nice brands you should consider include:
- Apexstone
- Jenaluca
- KitchenAid
- Norpro
- OXO Good Grips
- Solula
- Wilton
Warranty
Even if you don’t spend a lot on your cookie scoops, you should double-check the warranty and see if the manufacturer offers one. Some companies will offer a 30-day warranty, while others can offer one that protects you from defects and lasts a year or two. Once you find a warranty, check and see what it will protect against, how long it lasts, and what you have to do to claim it should your cookie scoop break.
Finish
The finish on your cookie scoop is like an additional layer of protection on your cookie scoop, and it also makes them look much nicer at a glance. Many products on our list had a mirror finish on them that made them shine, but this mirror finish also served to protect them from scratches, rust, and corrosion. The finish can make them easier to spot when you need them, and this includes when you work indoors and outdoors.
Best Cookie Scoop FAQ
Even though buying a cookie scoop doesn’t have to be a slow process, there are a few questions people ask over and over again. We’ve rounded them up for you below.
1. Is it worth it to buy a cookie scoop?
We believe that it is worth it to buy a cookie scoop because they have a host of advantages. You can use it to keep everything the same size to get a nice presentation, and having them the same size allows them to bake evenly.
2. What is the best size cookie scoop?
Generally speaking, the three-tablespoon-sized scoop is good for most cookies. They give you a slightly larger cookie, and this is the size that professional-level bakers use. You should have a few scoop sizes on hand to use when you bake, though.
3. How does the scoop release the dough ball?
Most cookie scoops have a sweeping mechanism inside that will detach the dough from the inside of the scoop when you press the release mechanism on the handle. It can be a spring-loaded mechanism or a cog-and-ratchet mechanism, and both work well.